Economists generally agree that the best measure of whether a tax
change is progressive or regressive is the percent by which it changes
the after tax-incomes of various income groups. Across-the-board rate
cuts raise after-tax incomes by a larger percentage for those at the top
of the income scale than for those at the middle and bottom, meaning
they are regressive. (Cutting all rates by the same number of
percentage points, rather than the same percentage, is also regressive.)
To
understand why cutting rates by an equal percentage produces unequal
results, consider a simple tax system with two rates: 20 percent and 40
percent. Assume that both tax rates are reduced by 50 percent, so that
the new bottom rate is 10 percent and the new top rate is 20 percent.
These rate cuts enable taxpayers to keep 90 cents — rather than 80
cents — of each dollar taxed at the bottom rate, generating a 12.5
percent increase in after-tax income.
[3] But, for each dollar taxed at the
top rate, taxpayers will keep 80 cents, rather than 60 cents, generating a
33 percent increase in after-tax income.
[4]
Thus,
even though both tax rates fall by the same percentage, the result is a
regressive tax cut that benefits people in the top bracket the most,
not only in dollars but in the percentage increase in their after-tax
income.
- Low-income taxpayers who have all of their
income taxed at the bottom rate will get a 12.5 percent increase in
their after-tax income.
- For taxpayers with incomes high
enough to face the higher tax rate, the percentage increase in their
after-tax income will be somewhere between 12.5 and 33 percent: they
will take home 12.5 percent more of their income taxed in the lower
bracket and 33 percent more of their income taxed in the higher
bracket. The more income they have taxed at the higher rate, the closer
their total increase in after-tax income will be to 33 percent.
The
same principle holds for tax codes with more than two rates, like the
federal income tax code. Higher-income taxpayers, who face the top tax
rates, would receive a bigger percentage boost in after-tax income from
across-the-board marginal income tax rate cuts than low-and
moderate-income taxpayers, who face only the lower tax rates.
Estimates
from the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center (TPC) starkly illustrate
this. (See Figure 1.) A 20 percent cut to all current marginal income
tax and AMT rates
[5]
would raise average after-tax incomes by 4.4 percent among millionaires
but by only 1.7 percent among taxpayers with incomes between $50,000
and $75,000. As Table 1 shows, these percentages work out to average
tax cuts of $92,400 for millionaires and $919 for middle-income
taxpayers.
http://www.cbpp.org/cms/index.cfm?fa=view&id=3807
Where do federal dollars go?
http://www.cbpp.org/cms/index.cfm?fa=view&id=1258
Who pays taxes:
http://www.cbpp.org/cms/index.cfm?fa=view&id=3505
The fact that most people who don’t owe federal income tax in a given
year do pay substantial amounts of other taxes — and also are net
income
taxpayers over time — belies the claim that households that do not owe
income tax in a given year will form bad policy judgments because they
“don’t have any skin in the game.”