Sunday, March 20, 2011

Liberal Economics:

Issue #20, Spring 2011

First Principles: Arguing the Economy

No debate is more fundamental in politics than economics. It’s the sun; everything else revolves around it.

This debate has never been more important than it is today. As the economy slowly rouses itself from its long slumber, it’s vital that progressives are adequately armed for the economic battles to come. We need forward-looking arguments that take new economic realities into account, and stronger ways of showing how badly supply-side economics has failed the country.
In this second installment of our “First Principles” series, we take on these challenges. Leading off the package, Andrei Cherny writes of the need today to use “Jeffersonian means to Hamiltonian ends”—to adapt our top-down economic policies to the bottom-up world of individualized workplaces, which are more and more central to our post-industrial economy with each passing year. We hope progressive policy-makers heed his notions about how to rethink our economic policies in what he calls the “Individual Age.” David Madland lays out a new theory of the middle class. It is not merely that a healthy middle class should be an end in and of itself, as progressive politicians have usually argued. Rather, it is that a strong middle class is a means to better social ends: It produces higher rates of growth, leads to more trust, and brings on better governance. This is an important linkage that progressives usually don’t make.

Since Madland’s and Cherny’s lessons will take time to seep into the bloodstream, we need to chalk up some wins in the meantime. We asked Elaine C. Kamarck to describe three economic fights that progressives should pick now, in the short term, even as we recalibrate our long-term thinking. What she suggests may surprise you.

But returning to our first principles is only half the battle. We also need to take on the conservative ideas that led to our current predicament. Paul Pierson explains the damage conservative economic policies have done to the country and shows how—in toxic combination with the concomitant increase in the importance of lobbying and campaign money—those policies altered our political system, making it far more responsive to the wealthy and far less responsive to the middle class. It’s a history lesson every liberal needs to know and internalize.
Finally, Jonathan Chait looks at the principle that most defines conservative economics today: taxophobia. Chait reminds us of some dark corners not often visited, and makes a point that should be more central to progressive arguments than it is: that what conservatives really care about above all else is protecting the well-off from any hint of redistribution. That’s a devastating charge; a shame we don’t hear prominent progressives make it more often.
First Principles: Arguing the Economy
Individual Age Economics by Andrei Cherny
Growth and the Middle Class by David Madland
Three Fights We Can Win by Elaine C. Kamarck
Inequality and Its Casualties by Paul Pierson
The Triumph of Taxophobia by Jonathan Chait

Economic Fundamentalism

http://www.democracyjournal.org/20/the-triumph-of-taxophobia.php


Issue #20, Spring 2011

The Triumph of Taxophobia

First Principles: Arguing the Economy

To read the other essays in the First Principles: Arguing the Economy symposium, click here.
The conservative movement’s embrace of taxophobia is probably the most important development in American political life over the last three decades. It is the one quality that most distinguishes American conservative elites from conservative elites in other countries. They’re more likely to question climate science, more sanguine about people dying for lack of health insurance, and less xenophobic (which is rather nice). But above all—far above all—they hate taxes.
Taxophobia has spawned an epistemology of its own and has completely reshaped the landscape of American politics. It more than anything else has driven the widely decried rise in partisan conflict. More profoundly, conservative taxophobia has redefined the terms of the political debate. Two generations ago, economic liberalism meant Keynesian deficit spending and a rapidly expanding welfare state with little concern for deficits. Fiscal conservatism meant opposition to deficits and inflation. Today, the old fiscal conservatism has been embraced by the mainstream of the Democratic Party. The old fiscal liberalism has been confined to the margins, espoused by left-wing dissidents to the Democratic mainstream. And the Republican Party inhabits an otherworldly new realm that even the staunchest right-wingers of a generation before could scarcely have imagined. As the two parties trade power back and forth, the ideological basis for economic policy pingpongs between the old right and a loopy kind of far-right. Periods of Republican governance have grown increasingly disastrous, while periods of Democratic governance are largely consumed with staving off fiscal collapse.
How did this happen? All conservatives, and many liberals, explain this transformation as the story of the rise of a new idea. But I don’t think that’s right. As I will explain, ideas only serve to rationalize political and economic self-interest. However, the story does begin with a new idea.

The Birth of a Notion
In the mid-1970s, the new doctrine of supply-side economics suddenly emerged on the right. The doctrine took what had been a marginal notion within the economics profession—the idea that higher tax rates can dampen the incentive to work and innovate—and elevated it to something close to a religion. The supply-side creed held that tax rates, especially on the rich, had enormous effects on economic growth. It was even possible, the supply-siders famously promised, that tax cuts could unleash so much economic growth that the net effect would increase tax revenue.
Jude Wanniski, a Wall Street Journal editorial writer who did more than anybody else to formulate and spread the new doctrine, spoke of the new creed in quasi-religious terms, as did many of his adherents. “It was Jude who introduced me to Jack Kemp, a young congressman and recent convert,” recalled Irving Kristol, who helped spread the gospel of supply-side economics. “It was Jack Kemp who, almost single-handed, converted Ronald Reagan...”

"Opposition to the progressive income tax is at once a sacred and a hidden value for Republicans, and thus one that makes compromise nearly impossible."

"Not long ago, House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan—who enjoys unparalleled prestige on budget issues among conservatives of all stripes—railed against the deficit and was asked about the massive cost of extending tax cuts. He replied, “Keeping tax rates where they are, and preventing them from going up, is not spending, because that is people’s money in the first place.” What on earth could this mean? Here is the answer. Ryan has declared his deep intellectual debt to Ayn Rand. He required all his staffers to read her work. When he responds to a question rooted in simple accounting with a moral claim (“people’s money in the first place”), he is saying that the arithmetic of revenue, outlays, and deficits does not matter to him. None of the pecuniary issues that he claims to care about so deeply ultimately matter. He is fighting a class war, which he views as a war for freedom itself."

"We can identify three phases of supply-side craziness in Republican Party history." [notice he goes from the metaphors of "religion" to "crazy".

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Center for American Progess: Prt 2: Founding

Progressives believe that a dogmatic opinion of the Constitution as a fixed document
requires not only the suspension of advanced knowledge collected over
time, but also a bizarre acquiescence to illiberal opinions from centuries past.
Treating the Constitution this way would mean reviving the Founders’ original
intent regarding slavery and excluding most men and all women from voting and
other forms of democratic life. (Progressive: Founding: 6)


The colonists complained most famously that they were required to pay new taxes imposed upon them by institutions that did not include representatives from the colonies. It is important to note
that the colonists were not opposed to taxation as a general rule, but to taxation
imposed by nonrepresentative institutions.


“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are
endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are
Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” Progressivism has always been about
the search for liberty, equality, and happiness for all within a system of democratic
government and social and economic opportunity. 8


Yet early progressives recognized as the nation’s economic situation changed
that the original ends of Jeffersonian thought would have to be adapted to new
forms of government. As Dewey wrote, “[T]he interests originally represented by
Jefferson…have now changed places with respect to exercise of federal power. For
Jeffersonian principles of self-government, of the prime authority of the people, of
general happiness or welfare as the end of government, can be appealed to in support
of policies that are opposite to those urged by Jefferson in his day.”9/14

Center for American Progess: Prt 1: Intellectual

Center for American Progress: Prt 1: Intellectual Heritage
Thomas Jefferson: "Some men look at constitutions with sanctimonious reverence, and deem them like the arc of the covenant, too sacred to be touched. They ascribe to the men of the preceding age a wisdom more than human, and suppose what they did to be beyond amendment. I knew that age well; I belonged to it, and labored with it. It deserved well of its country. It was very like the present, but without the experience of the present; and forty years of experience in government is worth a century of book reading; and this they would say themselves, were they to rise from the dead. I am certainly not an advocate for frequent and untried changes in laws and constitutions. I think moderate imperfections had better be borne with; because, when once known, we accommodate
ourselves to them, and find practical means of correcting their ill effects. But
I know also, that laws and institutions must go hand in hand with the progress of the
human mind. As that becomes more developed, more enlightened, as new discoveries
are made, new truths disclosed, and manners and opinions change with the change of
circumstances, institutions must advance also, and keep pace with the times. We might
as well require a man to wear still the coat which fitted him when a boy, as civilized
society to remain ever under the regimen of their barbarous ancestors." (Thomas Jefferson who wrote in 1816)

Justice Louis Brandeis, Holmes’ colleague, is especially eloquent on this point. Brandeis
explained in his famed essay, “The Living Law,” that the meaning of the American
Constitution necessarily shifted as democracy “deepened” over time. First pursuing a
“government of laws and not of men,” Americans later sought “a government of the people, by the people, and for the people,” and finally pursued “democracy and social justice.”
It should be noted, however, that Brandeis believed his argument to be well within the
American founding tradition. He considered Alexander Hamilton “an apostle of the living
law,” since he always considered the law to be “ a reality, quick and human, buxom and
jolly, and not a formula, pinched, stiff, banded and dusty like a royal mummy of Egypt.” (p.11/footnote 28)

Pragmaticism: "James formulated the same idea in somewhat more straightforward
terms: “The pragmatic method in such cases is to try to interpret each notion by
tracing its respective practical consequences. What difference would it practically make to
anyone if this notion rather than that notion were true? You must bring out of each word
its practical cash value, set it at work within the stream of your experience.”33

"The meaning of natural rights in pragmatic terms consisted of
their effects. If the traditional interpretation of the right to amass property resulted in
suffering, exploitation, and inequality, then this was the real meaning of this principle. It
remained for voters and political leaders to consider if these consequences were in keeping
with the good of the community, but Dewey was convinced that they were not." 13

While American individuals at the founding sought protection from government intervention in
their private lives, 20th century Americans found their lives more dangerously determined
by massive economic and social forces. Dewey wrote, “Present evil consequences are
treated as if they were eternally necessary, because they cannot be made consistent with
the ideals of another age. In reality, a machine age is a challenge to generate new conceptions
of the ideal and the spiritual.”38

In his famous essay, “Two Concepts of Liberty,” philosopher Isaiah Berlin argues that there are two fundamental ways of understanding liberty. Negative liberty is the freedom from formal coercion, restraint, or limits. It is closely linked to the classical liberal school of political thought. Positive liberty is the freedom to pursue and achieve ends. It is often considered in terms of human individual flourishing. Individuals are free insofar as they are capable of pursuing the ends they choose. Dewey took this to be the true meaning of liberty in a modern democratic state.40

The Role of Science: Since progressives argued that public policy ought
to be designed to serve the common good, many enthusiastically applied the scientific
method to the study of politics. Invigorated by recent successes in the natural sciences,
progressives believed that economic and political science could help to improve public
policy’s effectiveness and accountability. Modern sociology and psychology provided progressives with helpful evidence in support of political change. In many cases, this approach
led to new, comprehensive shifts in the approach to longstanding political problems. This
was particularly useful for adjudicating between competing interests in the political, economic,
and social spheres, since it provided a way of stripping away rhetoric and exploring
the actual consequences of various policy approaches. Progressivism—the promotion of human autonomy within a democratic national community— thus provided Americans with the means and the ideas to shape their own lives and destinies in better ways. It provided them a viable way to free themselves from the tyranny of excessive corporate power and a corrupt political class without losing the positive effects of technology, industrialization, and capitalism. It made economic behavior subject to public regulation, instead of neglecting the domination of public institutions by economic interests. It paved the way toward the midcentury “mixed economy” that lifted living standards for millions of people, reduced poverty and inequality, and helped to create the vast American middle class.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Annotated Bibliography

Thomas Frank;

The Wrecking Crew: How Conservatives Rule
What's Wrong With Kansas
One Market, Under God

Robert Kuttner:

A Presidency in Peril
"We know now that gGovernment by organized money is just as dangerous as Government by organized mob...They are unanimous in their hatred for me--and I welcome that hatred.  (FDR, Madison Square Garden, Oct. 31, 1936) p. 42.

Friday, January 28, 2011

notes from "The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report" (2011):

 http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2010/08/inequality_and_crash_1?page=1

On Wall Street, where many of these loans were packaged into securities and sold
to investors around the globe, a new term was coined: IBGYBG, “I’ll be gone, you’ll
be gone.” It referred to deals that brought in big fees up front while risking much
larger losses in the future. And, for a long time, IBGYBG worked at every level.
Most home loans entered the pipeline soon after borrowers signed the documents (p. 36)

“Securitization was one of the most brilliant financial innovations of the 20th century,”
Rokakis told the Commission. “It freed up a lot of capital. If it had been done
responsibly, it would have been a wondrous thing because nothing is more stable,
there’s nothing safer, than the American mortgage market. . . . It worked for years.
But then people realized they could scam it.” (p.38)

Years later, Fed Chairman Greenspan described the argument for deregulation:
“Those of us who support market capitalism in its more competitive forms might argue
that unfettered markets create a degree of wealth that fosters a more civilized existence.
I have always found that insight compelling.” (p. 61)

Testifying before Congress in 1997, he framed the issue this way: financial “modernization”
was needed to “remove outdated restrictions that serve no useful purpose,
that decrease economic efficiency, and that . . . limit choices and options for the consumer
of financial services.” Removing the barriers “would permit banking organizations
to compete more effectively in their natural markets. The result would be a
more efficient financial system providing better services to the public.” (p.62)

During a hearing on the rescue of Continental Illinois, Comptroller of the Currency
C. Todd Conover stated that federal regulators would not allow the  largest
“money center banks” to fail. This was a new regulatory principle, and within moments
it had a catchy name. Representative Stewart McKinney of Connecticut responded,
“We have a new kind of bank. It is called ‘too big to fail’—TBTF—and it is a
wonderful bank.”

In 2004, commercial banks, thrifts, and investment banks caught up with Fannie
Mae and Freddie Mac in securitizing home loans. By 2005, they had taken the lead.
The two government-sponsored enterprises maintained their monopoly on securitizing
prime mortgages below their loan limits, but the wave of home refinancing by
prime borrowers spurred by very low, steady interest rates petered out. Meanwhile,
Wall Street focused on the higher-yield loans that the GSEs could not purchase and
securitize—loans too large, called jumbo loans, and nonprime loans that didn’t meet
the GSEs’ standards. The nonprime loans soon became the biggest part of the market—“
subprime” loans for borrowers with weak credit and “Alt-A” loans, with characteristics
riskier than prime loans, to borrowers with strong credit.
By 2005 and 2006, Wall Street was securitizing one-third more loans than Fannie
and Freddie. In just two years, private-label mortgage-backed securities had grown
more than 30%, reaching 1.5 trillion in 2006; 75% were subprime or Alt-A. (p. 130)

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac’s market share shrank from 57%
of all mortgages purchased in 2003 to 42% in2004 , and down to 37% by 2006. Taking their place were private-label securitizations—meaning those not issued and
guaranteed by the GSEs. (p. 105)

“The definition of a good loan changed from ‘one that pays’ to ‘one that could be
sold,’” Patricia Lindsay, formerly a fraud specialist at New Century, told the FCIC. (p. 132)

David Berenbaum from the National Community Reinvestment
Coalition testified to Congress in the summer of 2007: “The industry has
flooded the market with exotic mortgage lending such as 2/28 and 3/27 ARMs. These
exotic subprime mortgages overwhelm borrowers when interest rates shoot up after
an introductory time period.” To their critics, they were simply a way for lenders to
strip equity from low-income borrowers. The loans came with big fees that got rolled
into the mortgage, increasing the chances that the mortgage could be larger than the
home’s value at the reset date. If the borrower could not refinance, the lender would
foreclose—and then own the home in a rising real estate market. (134)

At the hearing, consumers testified to being sold option ARM loans in their primary
non-English language, only to be pressured to sign English-only documents with significantly
worse terms. Some consumers testified to being unable to make even their
initial payments because they had been lied to so completely by their brokers.”
Mona Tawatao, a regional counsel with Legal Services of Northern California, described
the borrowers she was assisting as “people who got steered or defrauded into
entering option ARMs with teaser rates or pick-a-pay loans forcing them to pay
into—pay loans that they could never pay off. Prevalent among these clients are
seniors, people of color, people with disabilities, and limited English speakers and
seniors who are African American and Latino.”136

The New York Fed, in a
“lessons-learned” analysis after the crisis, pointed to the mistaken belief that “markets
will always self-correct.” “A deference to the self-correcting property of markets inhibited
supervisors from imposing prescriptive views on banks,” the report concluded. (198)

In that special examination, OFHEO pinned many of the GSEs’ problems on their
corporate cultures. Its May 2006 special examination report on Fannie Mae detailed the
“arrogant and unethical corporate culture where Fannie Mae employees manipulated
accounting and earnings to trigger bonuses for senior executives from  to .”